Jeffrey's Grocery in New York's West Village offers a maritime-themed atmosphere with a focus on seafood and cocktails. Customers rave about the attentive and friendly service, highlighting the quick and friendly staff. The menu boasts a variety of must-try dishes such as old bay fries, mussels, oysters, crab dip, and Caesar salad. The lobster roll is a standout with a generous serving of meat and creamy texture. The oyster happy hour, offering 12 high-quality oysters for a deal, is a favorite among patrons. The outdoor seating provides excellent people-watching opportunities in the charming neighborhood. Overall, Jeffrey's Grocery is a gem with mouthwatering offerings and exceptional service, making it a top recommendation for those looking for a delicious seafood dining experience in New York City.